Page 1 of 2

Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:27 pm
by ThaBlackGuy
As far as I'm concerned there are 4 fighters that reached goat status. In no particular order those fighters are as follows:

Fedor
Silva
Gsp
Jones

Now everybody has an opinion but before u post some bullshit about a damn cejudo or mcjagger, realize this thread ain't for u and politely keep it pushin.

For the few remaining geniuses with half a brain, how would you order them. Setting aside all the pico and court stuff. We're taking strictly in the cage. And I know that's asking allot but challenge yourself haha.

I'm asking this cuz I'm considering putting Jones above fedor. Never thought I'd see the day... so I'm like

Fedor/ Jones
Silva
GSP

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:28 pm
by hawdrigoh
Fedor.

Image

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:34 pm
by bruins2012
Strength of competition;

GSP
Jones
Silva
Fedor



Highlights/Finishing Ability;
Hard to rank but GSP is 4th


Title Reigns/Defenses;
Fedor is 4th



:P

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:45 pm
by ThaBlackGuy
hawdrigoh wrote:Fedor.

Image


Well naw we ain't done ... u gotta finish the list genius :lol:

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:49 pm
by hawdrigoh
ThaBlackGuy wrote:
hawdrigoh wrote:Fedor.

Image


Well naw we ain't done ... u gotta finish the list genius :lol:


My apologies.

1. Fedor
2. Big Nog
3. Saku
4. BJ

Image

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:50 pm
by ThaBlackGuy
bruins2012 wrote:Strength of competition;

GSP
Jones
Silva
Fedor



Highlights/Finishing Ability;
Hard to rank but GSP is 4th


Title Reigns/Defenses;
Fedor is 4th



:P



Fedor 4th? Nah..

Remembering he beat bisping, and without mentioning two belts how can u put gsp over jones. And without saying pico lmao

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:53 pm
by ThaBlackGuy
hawdrigoh wrote:
ThaBlackGuy wrote:
hawdrigoh wrote:Fedor.

Image


Well naw we ain't done ... u gotta finish the list genius :lol:


My apologies.

1. Fedor
2. Big Nog
3. Saku
4. BJ

Image


Look I love big nog like everybody else... But my dude I CLEARLY stated this discussion is about goats! Get real

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2019 11:58 pm
by ThaBlackGuy
If u get a limb broken in the cage ur disqualied from the list... nah wait nevermind :lol:

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 12:24 am
by Mr Meow
I like this thread. GOAT status is very rare. Your 4 all deserve it especially with your criteria

I would throw in 2 more names for you to consider adding to the list


Bas Rutten. Matt Hughes. Jose Aldo


Please don't shout at he cat.

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 12:39 am
by DreadLobster
ThaBlackGuy wrote:As far as I'm concerned there are 4 fighters that reached goat status. In no particular order those fighters are as follows:

Fedor
Silva
Gsp
Jones

Now everybody has an opinion but before u post some bullshit about a damn cejudo or mcjagger, realize this thread ain't for u and politely keep it pushin.

For the few remaining geniuses with half a brain, how would you order them. Setting aside all the pico and court stuff. We're taking strictly in the cage. And I know that's asking allot but challenge yourself haha.

I'm asking this cuz I'm considering putting Jones above fedor. Never thought I'd see the day... so I'm like

Fedor/ Jones
Silva
GSP



Jones has the most impressive resume but...

Its hard for me personally to downplay blatant cheating, and 3 of the names on that list have been credibly accused of that.

So...

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 1:46 am
by bruins2012
ThaBlackGuy wrote:
bruins2012 wrote:Strength of competition;

GSP
Jones
Silva
Fedor



Highlights/Finishing Ability;
Hard to rank but GSP is 4th


Title Reigns/Defenses;
Fedor is 4th



:P



Fedor 4th? Nah..

Remembering he beat bisping, and without mentioning two belts how can u put gsp over jones. And without saying pico lmao




Because LW and WW are always the deepest divisions, with LHW and HW always being the shallowest divisions.

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 1:58 am
by abcd
hawdrigoh wrote:Demetrious.

Image

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 2:02 am
by abcd
ThaBlackGuy wrote:
hawdrigoh wrote:Demetrious.

Image


Well naw we ain't done ... u gotta finish the list genius :lol:

1Demetrious
2Fedor
3Silva
4Jones

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 3:55 am
by ThaBlackGuy
bruins2012 wrote:
ThaBlackGuy wrote:
bruins2012 wrote:Strength of competition;

GSP
Jones
Silva
Fedor



Highlights/Finishing Ability;
Hard to rank but GSP is 4th


Title Reigns/Defenses;
Fedor is 4th



:P



Fedor 4th? Nah..

Remembering he beat bisping, and without mentioning two belts how can u put gsp over jones. And without saying pico lmao




Because LW and WW are always the deepest divisions, with LHW and HW always being the shallowest divisions.

That's true but when fedor was establishing his goatness in pride, the hw div was a king. Nog, cro cop, juiced up wandy, randleman rip etc....
Love me some st Pierre tho.

Re: Let's talk about goats

PostPosted: Tue Jul 09, 2019 4:02 am
by ThaBlackGuy
DreadLobster wrote:
ThaBlackGuy wrote:As far as I'm concerned there are 4 fighters that reached goat status. In no particular order those fighters are as follows:

Fedor
Silva
Gsp
Jones

Now everybody has an opinion but before u post some bullshit about a damn cejudo or mcjagger, realize this thread ain't for u and politely keep it pushin.

For the few remaining geniuses with half a brain, how would you order them. Setting aside all the pico and court stuff. We're taking strictly in the cage. And I know that's asking allot but challenge yourself haha.

I'm asking this cuz I'm considering putting Jones above fedor. Never thought I'd see the day... so I'm like

Fedor/ Jones
Silva
GSP



Jones has the most impressive resume but...

Its hard for me personally to downplay blatant cheating, and 3 of the names on that list have been credibly accused of that.

So...

I swear y'all give zero fcks about rules of discussion. This guy highlights my already bold lettering and completely disregards it :lol: :lol:
But fr if gsp wrote a tell all book and admitted he was cheating like shiiit and didn't get caught hoe would u rank em
I mean lets face it... clearly he's just the best cheater among the four right. :wink: